6 VA disability myths, checked against the rules

Veterans pick up a lot of advice in waiting rooms and online. Some of it is right. Some of it has quietly cost people money or months. Here are six I hear again and again, each checked against the regulation or VA's own pages.

1

MythMy ratings add up: 50% plus 30% makes 80%.

Fact

VA doesn't add ratings. It combines them, starting with the highest, and each new rating applies only to what's left. The rule is in 38 CFR § 4.25, and the regulation's own example is a 50 and a 30.

StepMathResult
First rating50% of the whole person50
Second rating30% of the remaining 50+15
Combined65, rounded to the nearest 1070%

Check your decision letter against the table. Try your own numbers in our VA calculator.

2

MythIf it wasn't diagnosed in service, I can't claim it.

Fact

The regulation says service connection may be granted for a disease diagnosed after discharge when all the evidence shows it was incurred in service (38 CFR § 3.303(d)). In practice VA looks for three things: a current condition, something that happened in service, and a medical link between them.

That link is the piece many claims are missing. It's what a Nexus Letter addresses.

3

MythVA disability pay gets taxed.

Fact

VA disability compensation isn't taxable income. You don't report it on your return. Military retired pay is a separate matter and generally is taxable, so if you receive both, a tax professional can tell you how they interact.

4

MythA denial is the end of the road.

Fact

VA offers three decision review options: a Supplemental Claim, a Higher-Level Review and a Board Appeal. For most benefits you have one year from the date on your decision letter to request a Higher-Level Review or Board Appeal. A Supplemental Claim can be filed any time, but filing within that year helps protect your effective date.

Which lane fits depends on why VA said no. See your three review options.

5

MythMy rating is set for life. I can't ask for more.

Fact

If a service-connected condition has gotten worse, you can file a claim for an increase on VA Form 21-526EZ, online or by mail. VA rates the condition on how it affects you now, so recent treatment records and an honest exam matter. Nothing is guaranteed, and VA can look at the whole picture.

Exam day counts. Here's how to prepare for your C&P exam.

6

MythI have to pay someone to file for me.

Fact

You can file yourself on VA.gov at no cost. VA also lists accredited representatives, and the services of an accredited Veterans Service Organization representative on a VA claim are free. VA's search tool lets you look up who is accredited.

What to do with this

Pull out your last decision letter. Check how your ratings combine, look at the date on it, and ask whether anything has changed in your health since the last exam. That ten minutes is where most missed opportunities show up.

Not sure what your record is missing?

Take the free Readiness Check. A few questions about your claim, and you'll see where the evidence may be thin. No cost, no pressure.

Start My Free Readiness Check
Dr. Robert Clinton

Dr. Robert Clinton is a former Army physician at Fort Bragg and a 100% service-connected disabled veteran. Since 2011 he has performed or taken part in more than 30,000 VA disability exams and DBQs. More about Dr. Clinton

References

  1. 38 CFR § 4.25, combined ratings table. LII
  2. 38 CFR § 3.303, principles relating to service connection. LII
  3. VA.gov: choosing a decision review option; file for disability compensation or an increase; get help from an accredited representative.
  4. IRS Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income. irs.gov

This article is general information, not medical or legal advice. Every claim depends on its own record. NEXUS Ready does not represent claimants and cannot guarantee any VA decision.

See if a Nexus Letter can help your claim

Start My Free Readiness Check

Call (910) 830-1587 (24/7) or email info@nexusready.net.